Best Italian food in Caldwell

Everyday Food That’s Always Made Fresh Daily

Order Online

(973) 403-7787

295 Bloomfield Ave Ste 2, Caldwell, NJ

Order now

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

White Pizza

Mozzarella & ricotta cheese

Add Item

Bolognese Pizza

Steak & grilled onions

Add Item

Vegetarian Pizza

Mushrooms, green peppers, onion & black olives

Add Item

Hot Pastrami Sandwich

With red roasted peppers & mozzarella

Add Item

Cheese Burger Plain

Add Item

Cedar Grill & Pizza Is All About Good Food

Right in the heart of Caldwell, Cedar Grill & Pizza is where great meals and good people come together. We serve up fresh dishes every day using locally sourced ingredients. Whether you're into pizza, fat sandwiches, Mediterranean bites, or classic Italian meals, we’ve got something you’ll love. Our casual spot has full-service and outdoor seating, perfect for a chill lunch or dinner with your crew.

Pick Your Favorite from the Menu

We keep it simple and fresh with a wide range of American, Mediterranean, and Italian dishes. From crisp salads to hearty fat sandwiches and stone-baked pizzas, there’s always something good coming out of our kitchen. Want to try something new? Our White Pizza is a local favorite and a great way to enjoy a Caldwell classic with your own twist.

See What’s Cooking

Order Online—It’s Easy

Ordering from Cedar Grill & Pizza is quick and simple. Whether you’re picking up or getting delivery, we’ve made it easy to enjoy your meal without the wait. Just a few taps and your food is on its way. Fast, fresh, and ready when you are.

Order Now

Real Food, Made Fresh, No Filters Needed

Take a peek at what’s coming out of our kitchen. These dishes look good—and they’re made fresh daily, just the way they should be.

Catering for the Big Days

Planning a party, office lunch, or family event? We’ve got you covered with catering options that bring your favorites to the table—fresh and ready to serve. Just let us know what you need and we’ll handle the rest. No stress, just good food and happy guests.

Let’s Plan This

Something for Everyone Here

Cedar Grill & Pizza is a go-to spot for locals, college students, tourists, couples, families, and groups of friends. The vibe is easygoing, and the service is full of care. Our outdoor seating gives you space to relax while you eat, and the menu makes it easy for everyone to find something they enjoy.

Come See Us Soon 📍

We’re right at 295 Bloomfield Ave Ste 2 in Caldwell, NJ. We’re open Tuesday through Sunday with hours that work for lunch, dinner, or a quick bite. Closed on Mondays, but here the rest of the week, ready to serve up something fresh. Stop by and see why so many call this their go-to pizza spot.

What our guests are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

The large plain pie is perfect and always cooked to perfection. The fat sandwiches are spot on and never miss. The new menu item momo is from my heritage, and I absolutely adore this and their recipe. The atmosphere and new owners are 10/10, and I will be coming back.

Viraj M.

The food here is so, so, so good. Now they have specials every Sunday. Today we got the Gobi Aloo, tadka daal, rice and naan. This is my go-to spot for Nepali momo. Owners are also super sweet. We love going here; it’s like a lovely, cosy neighbourhood restaurant!!

Rachana D.

One of the best places to have a "fresh" pizza experience. I have not been back here for a long time, but the pizza is still as amazing as the first time. It is hard to find consistent food quality. Like many foods, you have to eat it out of the oven. Takeout is something else.